Used Cars to Avoid (2013) | Consumer reports
American cars are reliable, and is it even matter.
It is 2013, but the stereotypes of American cars of the 70s still remain the automotive industry, buyers wonder if the domestic car can never be as reliable as imports.
Over the past six years, the Consumer Reports annual report cards indicate that domestic automakers are sitting between the package bottom in terms of reliability and assessments satisfaction On a score of 100, the three major domestic automakers on average 7 score of just 55 individually Ford ranks first with an unimpressive score of 63 1 during the same period, with an average 56 1 GM and Chrysler averaged a mere 48 abysmal.
JD Power also shows that a number of domestic automakers below the figures of the industry average regarding problems per 100 Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep and Ram are the worst depending on vehicle study JD Power Dependability 2012 with GMC and Chevrolet also perform below the industry average.
In addition, these car manufacturers don t get the nod from Consumer Reports, the percentage of vehicles recommended by year often dipping below 50 is a bit worrying when Chrysler as a whole, 0 Recommended cars in 2009.
An important factor in the search to the reliability of these cars comes with many reminders that are sent, for example, Ford announced serious reminders to the latest models of the Ford Escape and Fusion, two all new vehicles in markets very competitive compact Chevrolet Cruze also a reminder linked to alarming fire, which affected each model sold as missteps they seem to be common for domestic manufacturers.
It just shows that most domestic manufacturers have teething problems with their new products, said Anita Lam, head of the automotive Statistician Consumer Reports points out that these Lam domestic automakers tend to have problems at the beginning of the life of a new car, which was later fixed in the following updates to the product thus obtained a good point of reliability, Lam said, but Sá vicious circle as they then undergo a redesign or add better performance and reliability plunges again.
Lam says that these questions aren t the only sore spot with domestic automakers Consumer Reports found significant problems regarding the build quality we have seen significant deficiencies and problems with the alignment of the door during testing she said these lines well with what JD Power reports in its annual report quality assessment by the brands with national manufacturers such as Dodge and Ford with the lowest possible marks in overall quality.
There also seems to be a bit of a problem when an automaker is trying to jump ahead Lam point to new technologies such as MyFord Touch, which is cool, but riddled with bugs, problems of use and necessary updates that tarnish the luster of high-tech innovation.
The same can be said about Ford PowerShift transmission, which introduced the dual-clutch technology to its economy cars However, the performance and reliability are well below expectations, and Ford's reliability ratings have suffered.
Not everyone shares the view offered by Consumer Reports and J D Power Karl Brauer total score of cars seems to imply that domestic bashing is a bit of a fad, with no real basis today.
It really started in the early 1970s, says Brauer Build quality and energy efficiency and the same style for domestic cars suddenly couldn t compete with the rush of Japanese and to a lesser extent, European cars entering the US market, he said.
Looking at the scores of domestic vehicles on Total Car Score, it doesn seem t be an indication that domestic vehicles are unsatisfactory, prone to collapse or terrible to drive watch site assessments of the latest compact, the Buick Verano head the list with a score that ekes Subaru Impreza and Volkswagen Golf looking down the list and other American products like the Chevrolet Cruze, Ford focus and Dodge Dart stand out above the imports as the Hyundai Elantra, Kia Forte and Mitsubishi with these rankings in mind, Brauer argues that past misadventures of domestic automakers are still fresh in the minds of buyers.
The price spikes of the oil embargo and the resulting fuel 1973 really highlighted gas guzzling nature of big American cars while giving small Japanese cars suddenly an advantage because of their energy efficiency, Brauer States Since that time, Japanese continued to sell very fuel efficient and well-built cars in the US with some notable exceptions, while US automakers had to catch up in both areas.
Brauer emphasizes the SUV craze of 1990 and 2000, he argues that the time, domestic automakers have ceded the car market to imports in an effort to nab more profit margins by selling more trucks and SUVs However, when gas prices spiked again in 2005, no buyers were interested in fuel-hungry SUVs and popular domestic vehicles were left behind small cars that domestic manufacturers rushed to meet consumer demands are not as well built as import competition for domestic vehicles of that era were certainly behind the market leaders of Japanese automakers.
Brauer also argues that aren t reminders that significant in the grand scheme of things.
The all-new Ford Fusion is a great car overall, but there were reminders during launch that reflect a need for Ford to further improve its quality assurance process for all new cars, he said the same situation existed for the new Ford Escape it's great crossroads in general, but there were too many reminders at launch.
In the long term, these gift reminders t matter nearly as much as the style of the vehicle, handling, fuel efficiency and value equation prices, so these two models should still prove to be a big seller for Ford, said -he.
Yet there's no doubt that domestic manufacturers like Ford are still catching up to play to be on par with Japanese, Korean and European manufacturers, they had t shouldn as reminders of two all-new very large models, says Brauer.
However, if the number of recalls indicate a car manufacturer for quality and reliability, the import market is not immune widespread recalls.
This year, Toyota has exceeded the number of recalled vehicles in the United States, making it three years in the last four Toyota took the top spot in this shameful ranking It is also worth noting that the automaker sitting at second place is usually considered reliable Honda Even with the high number of recalls, both automakers are regularly considered to have the best reliability scores, meaning they aren t as big of a long-term problem .
After the two big Japanese manufacturers is GM, Ford and Chrysler, with Ford being recognized as having the most recall campaigns this year.
Consumer Reports Lam explains that there is a bright spot regarding domestic automakers We also conduct owner satisfaction surveys, which indicate that the donation buyers t seem to care about making the car as long as it meets expectations.
A market segment that sees a lot of positive results is the green car segment Chevrolet Volt owners, for example, like their car, she said them Ninety-two percent would buy another.
She also explained that the greedy V8 muscle cars with fuel and performance cars, like the Dodge Charger, Chrysler 300C and Chevrolet Corvette getting above the average owner satisfaction scores There are performance expectations, and these cars really come through, she said.
Brauer agrees that the work domestic manufacturers put in the alternative fuel technology pays off, remarking on the Chevy Volt, upcoming Cadillac ELR, Ford C-Max and Fusion Hybrid and vehicles Energi It seems that domestic include not only the current need for a good product, but the constant innovation of the future product, says Brauer.
Other areas of technology are also regarded more critically by the automaker's work we're seeing already the Cadillac CUE system, Ford Sync and Chrysler Uconnect Access suggests they understand this important field and won t let themselves fall behind, Brauer said at the Consumer Electronics Show this year, Ford and GM have announced initiatives to bring more connection, innovation and applications to their infotainment systems.
As German vehicles, despite the difficult scores for reliability, domestic manufacturers tend to occupy an important place in automotive performance, execution Layout APEAL rankings with American brands sitting around the industry average in the study annual JD Power.
It's hard to ignore the blatant reminders and a small number of vehicles recommended by mainstream publications, but it appears that the buying public did just that, instead of promoting other factors and make cars like the Ford Focus the sixth best-selling car in America in 2012.
I put 57,000 miles on my 2010 Toyota RAV4 without any problem at all mechical However, the amount reminders for my car Toyota is still baffling you to think that a company like Toyota would have done enough research and testing before releasing their cars on public BTW, while my RAV4 is quite reliable, the body of material is filled with bells and creaking After purchasing 4 Toyota brand new in 10 years for my family, I'm done with the company its quality slides lower.
CR selling their magazine to Japanese buyers who buy this magazine Whoever BELIVE that the Japanese are the best and that will answer their inquiry who bauht magazine A dog that chases it s tale I own a Ford Focus and the transmission grid and my Ford touch outperformed competitors one of my friends got an Acura system in her sewing so archaic compared to mine if MyFord is so bad it is a calamity, but CR is not the eye to see, because love is blind and they like Japanese.
Subaru reliability crown, but their range and volume of sales is relatively low Stories agreements and corolla hit 500k miles are many similar stories Malibus or Neons ever heard What a pleasure your touch screen is compared to Acura of a firend means nothing in terms of reliability.
What is not mentioned about the fire Cruze recall is that the fire was caused by the vehicle in one of the cases reported This was not a mechanical malfunction that made, fires occurred when someone would carry out an oil change and not clean any oil spill that may have collected on the engine start shield that would then ignite if the oil residue hot this recall was simply due to maintenance work sloppy, not a defect of the vehicle to prove that what happened to the call to solve the problem is that GM simply cut the middle part of the mudguards of the Cruze They do not change any room mechanical in the car.
I do not think the American automobile stigma will disappear until the US automakers consistently produce vehicles with fewer recalls, and cars that last and beyond the 100K mark, 150K as easily as foreign vehicles Yes, there are reminders on foreign manufacturers as well, but the reality is that foreign vehicles seem to hold much better at high mileage that American cars have in the past.
I owned one Toyota and that was enough, never had a friend like Dany RAV4 and here there was a rattle-box, but his unreliable over what I have not faith in JD Powers and less less for CR they blatantly omit things, is the latest edition even mention Toyota door fires, but they still get the green light.
We have 5 Toyota s in the family, Tundra 3 s, 1 RAV4-6cyl, 1 Camry We had some problems with any of them some reminders were prevension guy just in case I thank Toyota for What most poeple gift to t is MAITANANCE You must take care of your vehicle Nothing is perfect Before buying a vehicle s that we have done extensive research and comparisons.
I have a Mercedes-Benz 300SE 1989 with 235,000 miles still under great performance.
In 15 years, I used 3 mechanics, they tell me to avoid American cars, but SUVs because they are more reliable and more expensive to repair because of the way things are arranged under the hood I owned a 89 Oldsmobile Cutlass bought 80,000 miles, 90,000 died, a 89 Ford Escort 90000, 120000, a 97 Honda Civic 60000, 210000, a 97 Mercedes C230 55000, sold 175000 My wife had a 2001 Toyota RAV4 that it has bought brand new in 2001, we just sell after it clocked 200,000 miles My Honda Civic, the RAV4 and C230 have never had to tow Ford and Oldsmobile, the other had, have been towed several times that I can count with my fingers.
I guess everyone has forgotten the old crown vics and the great Marquis Mercury Marauder, and the Lincoln Town Cars All important engine parts, transmission were rock solid and many police stations deplore the death the Crown Victoria.
Funny You chose the only cars that are less reliable than the US.
These articles on the reliability must be difficult to write, I appreciate, I agree with it, it seems that domestic automakers are suffering a lot of ups and downs and play catch up, while Japanese automakers seemed fairly consistent in terms of reliability and fuel economy taking my own experience into account While I see some cars from national automakers and Euro I think would be cool to have in their warranty period, at the moment I d, considers Japanese have for any payment over long-term ownership of cars and would simply lease the rest is a little sad.
Solid perhaps, but too large, heavy and useless beasts not only oil and gas but also in space or lack there of using space more efficiently they had space becomes a premium in cities in particular, and the cost of gas steadily increasing, I think it was only a matter of time and the natural progression that large, heavy, American cars were the way the dodo bird, no matter how they were or how strong a reliable 300hp AWD four-door Yaris as a police car now, it would be something that was never said you needed a big car to catch the bad guys .
My father 98 Nissan Sentra ran up to 230k miles with only one starter and alternator replaced around 190k He did not follow the interview well, and head gasket blown 230k, probably because of the low cooling.
I disagree When labor costs is double your competitors, you have to cut corners in materials and design to maintain competitive prices so highly paid unionized workers indirectly affect the quality of cars built LA- low.
I wonder how you or someone else making fun of American cars really know about cars or engines in general I haven t heard you or someone else give one reason why American cars are less reliable, fallacies that have no real mechanical reasoning.
Let's compare the sports car after all, they are the true measure of an engineering capacity of the manufacturers.
Lets take the Corvette ZO6 2015 Vette has a 6 2L supercharged pushrod V-8 that produces 650hp and 650 lb-ft of torque, all without revving past 6200 rpms If you think a job 3-4Lforeign rise past regime 8k to create RPMs less energy is both more reliable and more efficient, then you must follow a course of engineering But anyway, the technologies of Vettes gift kinematic chain t end there, it can disable its 4 Eco mode cylinders to over 30mpg on the highway when a pretty cool Vette 3500lbs with 650hp can get the same gas mileage as the 200hp 3000 lbs civic allow you to move on.
The Vette's much more than a great powerful sophisticated engine, it is a marvel of bumper to bumper engineering the space frame is all aluminum and stiffer than the Ferrari 458, Porsche 911 and Nissan GTR s while being lighter, is made more downforce to 150 mph that anyother car never tested in a wind tunnel, it stops 60-0 to 90 feet and a suspension, brake components and of the chassis which are considered the best in Brembo industry, Eibach springs, carbon separators, the roof, the hood and the body panels, the control tower mag, ect.
Now Vettes in the past have been criticized for their lack of interior quality, which has now been fully taken into account throughout the cabin is wrapped in soft leather, soft touch plastic and features of the technology approach luxury sedan levels.
The fact that this car can be had for 100k on his plate high level with all the options available is astonishing that it comes with a warranty of 5 years 100k miles is amazing Show me a Porsche, Honda, Toyota, Nissan, ferrari, Lexus or BMW that can compete with what they can just t.
Now that's just a car, but the same argument can be made for just about every American car these days when it comes to class comparisions offers the widest range of choice of vehicles and now we can do without sacrifice anyone to initial quality still goes by the stigma that American cars are inferior, is simply living in the past.
Yet I have a Silver Birch Marauder and happier could not 2004 As Marcus said, panthers are very reliable, but saying they aren t waste would be lying.
Recalls yes, they are boring and probably American cars could do better.
But reliability is also on the high mileage clock capability without any maintenance apart from regular fluid changes Refueling and tire rotation and replacement of brake pads it shouldn t be that often if the car should not crash or have moving its trunk fail over and let the non-working trunk, or have its air suspension and cause the car to fail the list to one side until it's fixed.
At one point the German cars were indeed much more reliable than American cars of that view, the Japanese, needless to say, had and still have the top places.
But in recent years, American cars surged ahead of all European brands in this definition of reliability that I had a last generation Fusion without electrical or mechanical problem six years 120,000 km I swapped for a new current-gen Fusion hybrid and it's also being without great execution control problems no engine fires, no fault lights, no wipers do, and fancy electronic gadgets like parking sensors are all good condition.
All my friends who have German cars have fuel pumps or water pumps need replacement in less than 2 years, and check engine lights galore, and the fancy electronic luxury short films on the most problem impressive was a windshield wiper on a BMW fails and collide with each other, tearing immediately during a storm one friend in particular, is kicking himself after replacing an Acura who is 13 and 300,000 km with zero problems with a new diesel engine VW Touareg full load which saw 8 problems and 20 dealer visits in 2 years, and now diesel scandal left him unable to sell without taking a loss that would Fords seem as an investment.
In Europe, where Asian brands have always had a difficult time penetrating, Ford and GM subsidiaries such as Opel and Vauxhall sell very well as regular and reliable cars for the masses, and even managed to steal market share luxury namely trim charged Mondeo or Insignia.
American brands were crap, but now a second well-deserved place.
American cars are reliable and is it even matter »News, American cars, reliable, does.